Pate's Real Problem With The Jaden Daniels Saga Isn't The Jersey. It's Who Won't Own It.
The Pate State Staff on why Josh Pate thinks the Heisman-back demand is dumb no matter who's behind it — and why that ambiguity is the actual issue.
Pate did not wake up looking for a fight with Jaden Daniels. He woke up at 5 a.m., saw an ESPN headline, and assumed he was still asleep.
The headline: an attorney representing Daniels told LSU it can no longer use his name, image, and likeness, and that Daniels felt disrespected after the school let current quarterback DJ Picket wear his old number five. As Pate read the actual language on air: “An attorney representing Commander quarterback Jaden Daniels informed LSU it can no longer use his name, image, and likeness and said he felt profoundly disrespected after LSU allowed quarterback DJ Picket to wear his former number five jersey” By that afternoon it had escalated again — Daniels' camp reportedly wants LSU to hand back its own copy of the Heisman Trophy, and Lane Kiffin has personally gotten on the phone to try to settle it. As Pate relayed it: “He continues, "Daniels contacted LSU leadership before fall camp. Lane Keifin has personally spoken to Daniels."”
For context: Picket was reportedly promised number five by the previous LSU staff, Brian Kelly reversed that promise last year, and Kiffin — new to the job — restored it. That's the entire chain of events. A jersey number, passed around by three different regimes, somehow produced an NIL cease-and-desist letter and a request for a trophy back.
Pate's actual argument isn't really about the number. It's about ownership. He laid out two theories for how this got out of a phone and into an ESPN headline.
“So, there are two possibilities here, really.” The first: Daniels himself is steering it. “Possibility number one, Jaden Daniels himself is driving this, in which case it's one of the most mind-numbingly stupid cell phones in recent college football memory.” The second, and the one Pate leans toward, is that Daniels is deep in Commanders training camp and someone in his circle picked this fight with time on their hands and nothing better to do. Either way, Pate's verdict was blunt: “Either way, it's a terrible look. Either way, it is not even pennywise pound foolish because I don't know where the penny wise comes out of this.”
Run the actual math and the theory falls apart before it starts. Daniels won a Heisman at LSU after transferring in from Arizona State. Cutting the school off from his name and likeness doesn't punish LSU — it erases his own connection to the program that made him a first-round quarterback. Pate's summary needed no embellishment: “So, it's not even Pennywise pound foolish. It's just dumb. It's just stupid.” Whatever the intended message, the actual outcome looks like a professional athlete threatening his own alma mater over a number a teammate is wearing.
Here's where Pate's argument sharpens into something more specific than "this is silly." Daniels later posted a screenshot on Instagram that said plenty of words and confirmed almost nothing, except that a team — his team — is handling this. Pate's response to that non-answer was the actual thesis of the segment: “Sometimes you just got to man up and take responsibility, right? Like if you're telling someone, "Give me my Heisman back and stop putting my name in your mouth." Just say it's you.” If it's not him, Pate argued, the fix is just as simple — get whoever is running this out of the camp, or at minimum, stop letting them make calls with his name attached. A grown man playing quarterback in the NFL doesn't need a proxy fight over a jersey number.
The honest complication here is that Pate is arguing about tone and accountability, not about whether Daniels has a point on the substance. There is a real, if thin, thread of sympathy in this story: Picket was reportedly promised the number by a staff that no longer exists, and reversed on by a staff that also no longer exists, before Kiffin restored it a third time. If you're Daniels and you feel like promises made to a teammate about your old number keep getting renegotiated without you in the room, irritation isn't unreasonable. What's unreasonable, in Pate's telling, is escalating that irritation to an NIL freeze and a trophy request instead of a phone call — which, notably, Kiffin already made.
Pate closed the LSU half of the argument by putting the whole saga in franchise context: “LSU though, even at its best, even in the best of times when LSU is humming, there's a crisis out of left field like every other week.” And then the line that actually separates respect from endorsement: “LSU has been many things. They've never been normal to the point where I celebrate it. I respect it, but I do not respect this. I do not think much of this at all.”
None of this moves the needle on LSU's season. It's a jersey number, a lawyer's letter, and a trophy nobody is actually going to ship anywhere. But Pate's real complaint travels further than LSU's locker room — it's aimed at whoever is standing behind Jaden Daniels making decisions in his name while he stays quiet. Watch the full segment for how Pate walks through both scenarios, and decide for yourself which is worse: the quarterback picking this fight, or the quarterback letting someone else pick it for him.
Watch the Full Episode
Articles are drafted from Josh Pate's College Football Show under the site's editorial standards and monitored by the editorial team — corrections are timestamped, never silent.